1. (PDF Download) Hamlet's Mill: An Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge And Its
  2. Hamlet's mill; an essay on myth and the frame of time
  3. Hamlet's Mill : Giorgio De Santillana :
  4. Hamlet's mill; an essay on myth and the frame of time

Hamlet's Mill. An essay on myth and the frame of time. GIORGIO de SANTILLANA . Professor of the History and Philosophy of Science M.l.T. and. HERTHA von. An Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge and. Its Transmission Through Myth. Hamlet's Mill. by Giorgio de Santillana and Hertha von Dechend. Hamlet's Mill: An Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge and Its Transmission .. Print/export. Create a book · Download as PDF · Printable version.

Language:English, Spanish, Hindi
Published (Last):29.07.2016
Distribution:Free* [*Registration needed]
Uploaded by: IVETTE

59121 downloads 161569 Views 35.56MB PDF Size Report

Hamlets Mill Pdf

Best Download [Giorgio De Santillana] ✓ Hamlet's Mill || [Mystery Book] PDF ä, Ever since the Greeks coined the language we commonly use for scientific. download Hamlet's Mill: An Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge And Its Transmission Through Myth on ✓ FREE SHIPPING on qualified. Hamlet's mill; an essay on myth and the frame of time. byDe Santillana, Giorgio, For print-disabled users. Borrow this book to access EPUB and PDF files.

Friday, January 20, Has Hamlet's Mill been "debunked"? I have been thoroughly enjoying the conversations and discussions I've been having as Author of the Month for January on the Graham Hancock website. The quality of the comments and insights that other participants have offered has been consistently excellent, and the discourse has been very valuable to me, helping me see the issues from different perspectives and offering many new avenues for future exploration. It is important to note that challenges and criticism of some of my arguments has also been very valuable. I believe it is always important to examine the assertions that others make this is related to the concept of " due diligence " discussed in other posts and it is also important to examine one's own assumptions and one's own analysis, and to be clear on the reasons that one has for arriving at various conclusions. Just going through the process of articulating one's own reasons to others is a valuable process. Further, as I have said before , we all have our own different strengths stemming from our own personal and professional experience and study, and we all also have gaps and biases and blind spots, such that community and conversation and discourse and the council of others is very valuable to bring in the strengths and experiences of others that are different and potentially complementary. As the great philosopher Rocky Balboa once said, "I got gaps, she got gaps: together we fill gaps" or words to that effect. With this in mind, it was worthwhile to respond to a challenge to the thesis put forward by de Santillana and von Dechend in Hamlet's Mill , which I believe to be a very important book and one that provides a great deal of valuable insight for anyone intent on understanding the evidence left to us from ancient civilizations in the form of mythology. It turns out that of the two "external references" provided for Hamlet's Mill in the current Wikipedia entry , one is a link to an online version of the entire book , and one is a link to an essay which is very critical of Hamlet's Mill and its authors, calling it "an amazing exhibition of academic narrow-mindedness, unrestrained speculation, and lack of expert knowledge, on the part of its authors. I give my reasons to believe that the essay does not prove that Hamlet's Mill has been "debunked" at all. On the contrary, I would argue that the examples the author brings out to "debunk" Hamlet's Mill when he finally gets around to bringing them out demonstrate his lack of understanding of their thesis and argument. Admittedly, Hamlet's Mill is a dense and somewhat convoluted read.

Though Jung might well have sponsored this enterprise, the authors sneer at both brands of depth psychology. Nor do fellow mythologists fare much better: Dum6zil, L6vi-Strauss and Joseph Campbell are not so much as mentioned, and Cassirer is dismissed in a few ill-natured paragraphs.

(PDF Download) Hamlet's Mill: An Essay Investigating the Origins of Human Knowledge And Its

But what is most exasperating about the book is the authors' coy way of paying out their findings. Just as a train of argument is about to come to the point, a digression is maddeningly introduced to heighten the suspense; the startling promises of topic sentences and paragraphs somehow never get realized in the tangle of forced facts and dubious speculations that follow.

To be sure, the book is full of fascinating items of learning and now and then an arresting idea emerges, but these tidbits hardly compensate for the frailty of the thesis and the overly calculated exposition.

Project MUSE promotes the creation and dissemination of essential humanities and social science resources through collaboration with libraries, publishers, and scholars worldwide.

Forged from a partnership between a university press and a library, Project MUSE is a trusted part of the academic and scholarly community it serves. Built on the Johns Hopkins University Campus. Of course I do not agree with every sentiment espoused by de Santillana and von Dechend, nor with every aspect of their own personal belief systems or with everything they did during their lifetimes.

But to mock them for things they did or believed during the decades that they lived which were very different times in the world of academia than those of today or of the past couple decades is both uncharitable and unhelpful.

I have published a blog post in which I point out that the "blind spots" of previous eras are often more obvious to us today than the "blind spots" that we have which we do not see ourselves. This fact is related to the literary trope in which mystery stories are almost always solved by an "outsider" see Sherlock Holmes or Scooby Doo. Now to my point about Mr.

Hamlet's mill; an essay on myth and the frame of time

Thompson's failure to understand de Santillana and von Dechend. He takes them to task in parts 2, 3, and 4 for things like this the quote is from Mr.

Thompson's essay : Erra is an Akkadian warrior god. The result of Erra's assault is that the world is plunged into darkness and as a result Marduk is displaced from his throne and forced to descend to the underworld.

Erra temporarily seizes control of Babylon from Marduk during the latter's temporary absence. As the phenomena of precession is completely unconnected with any occurrence of celestial darkness this type of imagery can hardly be descriptive of precession.

The theme of the chosen imagery of the Erra-Epic is believed to refer to a disastrous military event that occurred to the city of Babylon in the "dark age" at the beginning of the first millennium BCE.

To say that the displacement of a god, after which he is forced to descend into the underworld, "can hardly be descriptive of precession" is just plain wrong.

This is exactly the pattern we see in the Osiris myth in Egypt, as well as in the Kronos myth in ancient Greece, both of which can clearly be explained in terms of precession Jane Sellers does an excellent job explaining exactly how this can be seen as descriptive of precession in her well-known and well-written book Death of Gods in Ancient Egypt , and I discuss it at length in my own book and give some shorter discussion of the same topic on my blog in posts such as this one and this one.

In other words, the examples Mr.

Thompson brings up to discredit Hamlet's Mill do not discredit Hamlet's Mill at all if anything, they generally reinforce the arguments of de Santillana and von Dechend and show that Mr. Thompson does not understand their thesis. He brings up a book by William Thompson which interprets the fairy tale of Rapunzel as "involving the sun and moon and the planetary motion of Mercury, Venus and Mars.

Hamlet's Mill : Giorgio De Santillana :

In fact, the possibility that Rapunzel contains such information is further validation of their thesis Hamlet's Mill cites several cases in which folk tales appear to contain the same celestial information as epics and sagas contain, but using more "rustic" characters such as the farmer's cat instead of great heroes or warriors.

I have compared this to actors who appear in very different costumes in different movies or plays, but who are the same actors see this blog post.

Thompson is also critical of what he calls, "The influence of Higgins' concept of an ancient world-wide secret religious order sharing knowledge" and dismisses the idea on the basis that if such an order existed to share celestial scientific knowledge, then why didn't it also encode other knowledge, saying: "My only comment is why didn't the channels of communication - whatever they supposedly were - also get used to carry other technical information such as metalworking.

Its worth noting, that when the Maitreyasamiti texts were found, they were immediately readable because they were written in a classic Brahmi Sanskrit font. Despite being found in what is now NW China.

Hamlet's mill; an essay on myth and the frame of time

They found a false wall, and behind it a cache of thousands of scrolls, the above is but one. And that's just one temple.

We have ghost towns out west that were abandoned years ago. They have ghost towns, like Niya, that were abandoned over years ago. I also read of a mail bag found in the Kara Kum.

Related files

Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved.